Kodai Senga returned from the injured list Tuesday and lasted just four innings against the Cincinnati Reds, giving up four runs on two hits and four walks while striking out five, as the Mets dropped a frustrating 5-3 series loss with real deadline implications building around them.
Senga’s Return Was Overdue – The Four-Inning Performance Doesn’t Change That Yet
Kodai Senga posting a four-inning, four-run line in his first major league start back is not the return the Mets needed, but context matters enormously here. Senga missed most of the season recovering from a right shoulder capsule strain that shut him down in February, and his ramp-up through Triple-A Syracuse was deliberately cautious given the injury history.
Both things can be true simultaneously: the 2023 version of Senga – who posted a 2.98 ERA and 202 strikeouts in 166.1 innings and finished second in NL Rookie of the Year voting – is exactly the de facto ace this rotation desperately needs. The honest qualifier sits right next to that, though: four walks in four innings against the Reds is not a sign that version is back yet.
The Mets have cycled through depth options like Christian Scott and José Buttó while managing extended absences across the rotation, per local beat coverage, and Senga will remain in the rotation regardless of Tuesday’s result. The question is how quickly his command tightens under game-speed conditions rather than rehab-pace outings.
David Stearns Is Under Deadline Pressure – Buster Olney’s List Makes It Official
David Stearns ranked very high on Buster Olney‘s list of 12 baseball executives under the most pressure ahead of the trade deadline, and that ranking reflects a genuine front office crossroads rather than manufactured drama. The Mets‘ disappointing stretch in May and June has compressed the decision window considerably, with Stearns now weighing whether to sell soft, hold, or double down around Pete Alonso‘s walk year and the veteran core anchored by Francisco Lindor and Brandon Nimmo.
As this site’s Lindor injury coverage documents, the shortstop’s timeline is itself a variable Stearns must factor into any deadline posture. A healthy Lindor changes the calculus on whether this roster is worth buying around at the deadline versus cutting losses on fringe pieces.
The Mets also designated Vidal Bruján for assignment as part of Tuesday’s roster shuffle, a move beat writers have largely praised as Stearns aggressively churning the roster’s fringes. Utility infielder Zack Short was added for defensive versatility, signaling a preference for functional depth over Bruján’s limited offensive production.
NL East Rivals Keep Winning – The Phillies Gap Is Getting Uncomfortable
While the Mets dropped their series against Cincinnati, the Philadelphia Phillies handled the Miami Marlins 8-2 with Jesús Luzardo delivering a dominant seven-inning, two-run, nine-strikeout performance. Luzardo has been frequently mentioned in national trade rumor columns as a potential chip for a rebuilding Marlins club, and nights like Tuesday only inflate his value if Miami does pivot toward the future.
The Washington Nationals beat the Kansas City Royals 6-4, with Curtis Mead delivering the decisive blow on a three-run home run in the seventh inning. The San Francisco Giants–Atlanta Braves game was suspended in the second inning with the Giants leading 3-2, set to be completed today at 2 PM ahead of a 7:15 PM series finale.
The Mets have legitimate reasons for optimism in the NL East race, but the division is not waiting for them to get healthy and sorted. Every Phillies win tightens the margin for error on Stearns’ deadline decisions.
Around the League – Giants Available Players, Cubs Bullpen Blow, Mariners Returns
The San Francisco Giants are open to offers for Matt Chapman and Rafael Devers but have taken Logan Webb and their young core off the table entirely, per national reporting. That’s a meaningful distinction for deadline buyers – two high-value veterans are available, but the Giants are not blowing the roster up.
Chicago Cubs closer Daniel Palencia is heading to the injured list with right elbow inflammation, which is a significant bullpen development for a Cubs team chasing relevance. The Seattle Mariners got healthier, activating both catcher Cal Raleigh and shortstop J.P. Crawford from the injured list ahead of their homestand.
The Milwaukee Brewers called up Cooper Pratt for his major league debut, a notable moment given Pratt signed an eight-year extension with the organization months ago. And 18 years ago today, Willie Randolph was infamously fired as Mets manager in the middle of the night in Anaheim – a piece of franchise history that still stings for fans who lived through it.
About the Author
