The World Cup opens Friday at MetLife Stadium and Mauricio Pochettino still hasn’t told his goalkeepers who’s starting.
That’s not a narrative device – according to Matt Freese himself, the USMNT manager has not yet informed his players of his plan.
With the United States opening against Paraguay in less than 72 hours, arguably the most important position on the field remains officially undecided.
The Candidates: Freese Leads, Turner Looms
Freese is the frontrunner and has been for nearly a year.
The 27-year-old NYCFC keeper has started 12 of the last 14 USMNT matches, including all 90 minutes of Saturday’s 2-1 loss to Germany – a lineup that looked like a dry run for Pochettino’s opening XI.
ESPN’s World Cup coverage has called the job “his to lose,” and USA Today projected him as the No. 1 as far back as November 2025 after Pochettino effectively cast his lot with the MLS keeper.
Matt Turner is the counterweight. The Park Ridge, New Jersey native has 53 caps, started every match at Qatar 2022, and won the Golden Glove at the 2021 Gold Cup.
That’s the kind of résumé that doesn’t quietly sit on a bench – and in a tournament being played 20 minutes from his hometown, Turner’s presence on this roster is a genuine storyline whether he starts or not.
His path back to MLS after struggling for minutes at Nottingham Forest hurt his case, but experience matters in knockout football and Pochettino knows it.
Chris Brady, the 21-year-old Chicago Fire keeper with zero caps, rounds out the group as the long-term answer rather than a present-tense option. He’s here to learn, not to start.
Why It’s Still Open: The Case Breakdown
Freese’s hold on the job is real but not ironclad. He earned his first USMNT cap last June – just over a year ago – and has never played club football in Europe.
That’s not disqualifying, especially in an era where MLS quality has genuinely risen, but it’s context.
For the first time in the 30-year history of MLS, the U.S. World Cup starting goalkeeper is expected to come from the domestic league.
FOX Sports flagged that milestone explicitly, noting it’s “entirely possible – and perhaps even likely” that all three keepers on the final roster are MLS-based.
That’s a significant shift from the days of Tim Howard and Brad Guzan carrying the position with established European credentials.
Pochettino’s public non-answer – “We will see. Today, first time with the team, it’s good” when asked about Chris Richards returning to training – suggests a manager who is deliberately keeping his cards close.
Whether that’s genuine deliberation or tactical gamesmanship ahead of Paraguay is impossible to know. Either way, it’s unusual.
Our full USMNT World Cup roster guide laid out the goalkeeping competition months ago, and the answer still isn’t settled on the eve of kickoff.
Freese, for his part, is playing it exactly right. “I don’t hear the noise, not really,” he said at a training session in Irvine that drew 5,000 fans.
“I’m not really listening to anyone outside of the guys with me and the coaching staff.”
That’s the correct answer – and it’s also the answer of a man who believes he has the job.
The MetLife Factor: Why This Matters for NY/NJ
This goalkeeper decision carries extra weight in this market specifically.
Turner grew up in Park Ridge, New Jersey – less than 10 miles from MetLife Stadium.
He walked on at Fairfield University, went undrafted, and built himself into a World Cup starter through sheer force of will.
That’s a New York-area story, and local fans know it. The tri-state pipeline running through this USMNT roster makes Turner’s potential bench role genuinely uncomfortable – not just as a soccer decision but as a local one.
Freese counters with his own New York connection: he plays his club football at Yankee Stadium with NYCFC, and the city’s soccer fanbase has watched him develop into one of MLS’s better keepers over the past two seasons.
This isn’t an abstract national team debate in New York – both main candidates have legitimate local stakes in the outcome.
Any early mistake by the starter will immediately fuel calls for a switch, and in this market, those calls will be loud.
With MetLife hosting matches through the Final on July 19, the pressure on whoever gets the nod will only build as the tournament progresses.
Bottom Line: Freese’s Job, Turner’s Shadow
Pochettino is starting Matt Freese on Friday. The Germany audition, the Gold Cup track record, the 12 consecutive starts – the evidence points one direction. The official announcement just hasn’t landed yet.
But Turner won’t disappear from the conversation. One shaky performance, one defensive breakdown, and the debate restarts immediately – with a 53-cap World Cup veteran warming up behind him and 80,000 people at MetLife waiting to react.
Freese has earned this moment. Now he has to hold it.
About the Author
