Rey-YES

If we keep only 11 P-S pitchers, allowing 5 bench players + Castro, 4 of 'em would be Gotay, Endy, Green and Anderson. All LH except Gotay, who is best LH. We need 1 RH PH. Would it be--

Gomez, who looks completely overmatched but could PR or be a defensive replacement?

Conine, who has been absolutely awful since we got him, but has been good in P-S in the past?

Or DeFelice, who hopefully would never come to bat or play an inning unless we're up 13-0, but would allow us to use Castro to PH?

I really wanted Conine, but he's been a dud. And Gomez doesn't look ready.

My vote, by default, goes to DeFelice.

__________________
TPFKABM

Matt

You're kidding, right?

__________________
Outfield

Rey-YES

No. If we need a RH PH in the 9th, I'd take Castro over Conine and Gomez.

Who'd you want?

__________________
TPFKABM

Matt

I'd want to get into the playoffs first, perhaps?

__________________
Outfield

Dewitt Clinton

__________________
Ambler, revealing his true colors for all but him to see.

NeilAllen

LOL this thead is gold.

__________________
"Democracy is the theory that the common people know what they want and deserve to get it good and hard." --H.L. Mencken

MrHat

This thread kills me, but seriously, Castro has been a terrible PHer. Conine all the way.

MajorRanger35

Believe it or not, you can use Castro as a PH without having another C on the bench. It's called taking a risk. Teams do it all the time in October.

You can't be serious with the idea of having DiFeces on the PS roster, can you?

Bay Ridge Dave

While you're at it, let's give the ball to Sele in Game 1...

But to answer your question... Conine, because of the track record.

Led, the Revenge

__________________

Bay Ridge Dave

You sick Brit! LMAO!

Led, the Revenge

Biiiilll.... Come to Candy Mountain Biiiilll.....

It's full of joy and candy and joyness.

__________________

Bay Ridge Dave

A head shot of Mike Silva would top it all off....

Led, the Revenge

But... I'd have to gouge my eyes out while photoshopping it.

__________________

METSSC

Was Bill that lone Met fan in CBP today?

__________________
GET THE PIECE OF CRAP McGimpy OFF MY TEAM NOW!!!!!

The McGimpy does most things upside down: eats, sleeps (an average of 23 hours per day), mates, and gives birth. Because of the McGimpy's upside down life, many of the McGimpy's internal organs (liver, stomach, spleen, pancreas) are in different positions from other mammals. McGimpy sometimes lets out a cry or hissing sound.

During the rare times the McGimpy goes down to the ground (such as to change trees for food), it moves very slowly.