Originally Posted by Rey-YES

If we keep only 11 P-S pitchers, allowing 5 bench players + Castro, 4 of 'em would be Gotay, Endy, Green and Anderson. All LH except Gotay, who is best LH. We need 1 RH PH. Would it be--

Gomez, who looks completely overmatched but could PR or be a defensive replacement?

Conine, who has been absolutely awful since we got him, but has been good in P-S in the past?

Or DeFelice, who hopefully would never come to bat or play an inning unless we're up 13-0, but would allow us to use Castro to PH?

I really wanted Conine, but he's been a dud. And Gomez doesn't look ready.

My vote, by default, goes to DeFelice.